WillOTheWispA : I believe in the equality of women and men.
T : Why? Don’t you see it? And if you do, then why do you need to believe in it?
…
A : I believe in God.
T : This is a little confusing. Do you mean to say that God talks to you and you believe whatever he utters to be the Gospel Truth? Or do you mean to say that you believe that God exists as Conceivable Entity?
… I’ll not belabour this point here, though. This is worthy of independent development on the following lines …
A ( Furious! ) : Both!
T : They contradict each other.
A : What?!!!
T : They do. Look at them …
A : I just uttered the words and I don’t see any contradictions.
T : I note that you are asserting that God exists by virtue of his talking to you. He/She does not do so for me. Hence here is one part of your experience ( or being ) which is completely disjunct from mine. Hence, in any meaningful communication between us, we know that God must not be invoked or else I would have no clue to what you are talking about nor would it be a matter of our common human experience.
T : I also note that you assert that God exists as a conceivable entity which is open to misinterpretation – like, He/She exists only as a concept with no other Reality. The other interpretation would be God exists and is conceivable – which as you notice, is regressive.
A : This is serious! Don’t make fun of God …
T : Ouch! Sorry. I wasn’t making fun ‘of’ God as such, at most having a little fun with YOUR conception of Him/Her.
A : You’d be better off doing better than that …
T : So I intend to.
…
A : I believe in Justice.
T : Why?
A : What do you mean – Why?!
T : If someone were to say to me that he believed in Injustice, I would ask him the same question. Why?
…
Okay, this was just a bit of fun and games. But the idea was to get a glimpse of the kind of difficulties that Wittgenstein seems to have spoken of … 
A Little Game
Advertisement
